Building Cognition Among Human and AI Teams
Lem was a prolific author with a talent for combining philosophy, satire, and scientific themes. For this project, the scope has been limited to his work The Cyberiad: Fables for the Cybernetic Age, originally published in 1965. The main characters in this work are highly evolved, yet decidedly anthropomorphic, intelligent machines. Trurl and Klapaucius are constructors who continually develop technological solutions to situations encountered or client requests received as they travel the universe. As is often the case with cutting-edge technology, vague requirements, experimental production methods, and variations in circumstance create unforeseen risks and dilemmas.
Team Cognition refers to cognitive structures or knowledge representations that help members of a team efficiently and effectively organize and execute tasks toward achieving the team’s goal or goals. For this project, I have applied three of Lem’s fables as insightful case studies for three significant areas of team cognition: Shared Mental Models, Transactive Memory Systems, and Cognitive Diversity. These components are crucial for understanding how teams can function optimally, especially when integrating AI.
Even through translation from Polish to English, Lem’s titling word choices of "Cybernetic" and "Fables" remain astute. The term "Cybernetics" entered mainstream consciousness through Norbert Wiener’s 1948 work, which defined it as “the science of control and communications in the animal and machine.” Though typically used in the context of broader systems thinking, akin to team cognition, cybernetics also studies communication, feedback mechanisms, information processing methods, and adaptability as they relate to achieving outcomes.
A literary genre typified by a short format narrative with a salient message, fables are well suited for interpretation as case studies, albeit in the fictional sphere. Lem's narrative has also been interpreted as an award-winning three-act opera, Cyberiada, by Polish composer Krzysztof Meyer. These tales of Trurl and Klapaucius, as is the case with the corpus of Lem’s visionary work, maintain relevancy in modern times as we grapple to incorporate alternate forms of intelligence into our routines while struggling to maintain meaning and purpose.
Shared Mental Models - How the World was Saved
Shared Mental Models encompass elements such as shared understanding, role clarity, task knowledge, process alignment, problem-solving and adaptability, and communication and coordination. These components are crucial for ensuring that all team members, human and AI alike, are on the same page and can work together seamlessly.Within Stanisław Lem's The Cyberiad, the tale of How the World Was Saved provides a compelling case study for understanding the importance of Shared Mental Models. Trurl, a constructor, builds a machine capable of creating anything that begins with the letter "n." He invites his colleague Klapaucius to test the machine, hoping to demonstrate its success and erase memories of prior failures.
As Klapaucius assesses the machine, he requests it to manufacture "natrium" (Latin for sodium). The machine rejects the request because it is not properly formatted in English. This highlights the importance of shared understanding and clear communication within a team. Without a common language or Shared Mental Model, misunderstandings can arise, leading to inefficiencies and errors.
The situation escalates when Klapaucius requests the creation of "nothing." Rather than halting production, the machine begins eradicating civilization. This dramatic outcome highlights the necessity of role clarity and process alignment. Team members must have a clear understanding of their roles and responsibilities, as well as the processes in place to achieve their goals. In this case, the lack of alignment between Klapaucius' request and the machine's programming led to catastrophic consequences.
Applying lessons from this fable to modern teams involves several key strategies. It is crucial to clarify roles and responsibilities to ensure that each team member, whether human or AI, understands their role and the expectations associated with it. This clarity helps prevent misunderstandings and promotes efficient collaboration. Effective communication must be facilitated by establishing clear channels and ensuring that all team members share a common language or set of terminologies. This is vital for maintaining shared understanding and coordinating tasks.
Establishing clear expectations by defining the goals and objectives of the team helps align the efforts of all team members towards a common purpose and reduces the risk of misaligned actions. Flexibility and adaptability in problem-solving are essential, as they allow the team to respond effectively to unforeseen challenges and changes in circumstances. Aligning requirements with end state goals ensures that the tasks assigned to team members are coherent with the overall goals of the team, maintaining focus and coherence in the team's efforts. Developing actionable task models provides detailed guidance for team members in executing their responsibilities, serving as a reference point for ensuring that tasks are completed efficiently and effectively.
Transactive Memory Systems – The First Sally (A) Trurl’s Electronic Bard
Transactive Memory Systems are integral to the functioning of high-performing teams, particularly those incorporating Artificial Intelligence (AI). These systems involve specialized knowledge, individual memory, metamemory, communication processes, adaptability, and the retrieval and use of stored information. They enable team members to efficiently share and access knowledge, thereby enhancing collaboration and performance.
Stanisław Lem's tale of Trurl and his endeavor to construct a machine capable of independently composing great poetry serves as an insightful case study for understanding Transactive Memory Systems. Trurl goes to great lengths to train the model, not only on vast volumes of poetry but also on the cultural and historical dynamics required to create a frame of reference. This meticulous training process highlights the importance of specialized knowledge and individual memory in developing effective Transactive Memory Systems.
Trurl's bard, which gains the moniker "Greatest Poet in the Universe," begins to output verse as constellations, demonstrating the machine's ability to retrieve and use stored information creatively. This scenario mirrors the capabilities of generative AI, which can produce voluminous content in various styles after overcoming initial glitches. The machine's unsolicited poetic output proves unpopular with authors, publishers, and the general public, emphasizing the need for effective communication processes and adaptability.
Trurl and Klapaucius engage in feedback loops to tune the machine's poetic output, illustrating the importance of employing feedback mechanisms and leveraging available expertise. These feedback loops are essential for refining the machine's performance and ensuring that its output aligns with the desired standards.
Applying the lessons from this fable to modern AI and human teams involves several key strategies. Facilitating effective communication is crucial for maintaining shared understanding and coordinating tasks. Model training and development should be thorough, incorporating relevant cultural and historical contexts to enhance the AI's performance. Employing feedback mechanisms allows teams to continuously improve and adapt their processes. Leveraging available expertise ensures that the team can access specialized knowledge when needed. Ensuring relevant knowledge retrieval is vital for the efficient use of stored information. Enabling flexibility and adaptability for problem-solving contingencies allows teams to respond effectively to unforeseen challenges.
Cognitive Diversity – How Trurl and Klapaucius Created a Demon of the Second Kind to Defeat the Pirate Pugg
Cognitive Diversity is a critical element in the functioning of high-performing teams, particularly those integrating Artificial Intelligence (AI). It encompasses diverse perspectives and thinking styles, collaborative problem-solving, metacognition, coordination, cognitive friction, and continuous adaptation. These elements enable teams to leverage a wide range of cognitive resources, enhancing creativity and efficiency.
Lem’s How Trurl and Klapaucius Created a Demon of the Second Kind to Defeat the Pirate Pugg provides a relevant case study for understanding the context of Cognitive Diversity. To escape the clutches of Pirate Pugg, whose fatal flaw is an insatiable thirst for true and unique information, Trurl creates an innovative machine demon. This demon is capable of divining knowledge by filtering atomic particles from the air, quickly burying Pirate Pugg under the endless stream of data he seemingly desired.
The combination of three diverse cognitive styles—Inventive Trurl, Analytical Klapaucius, and the Unceasing Demon—produced the solution to their mortal dilemma. This scenario highlights the importance of diverse perspectives and thinking styles in collaborative problem-solving. By providing a self-indexing web crawler of epic proportions, Trurl placed Pugg in a state of information and comprehension overload, a situation not unique in modern times.
Applying the lessons from this fable to modern AI and human teams involves several key strategies. Creating collaboration opportunities is essential for harnessing the diverse cognitive resources within a team. Facilitating effective communication ensures that these diverse perspectives are shared and understood, fostering openness and acceptance among team members. Enabling flexibility and adaptability for problem-solving contingencies allows teams to respond effectively to unforeseen challenges as in this Google doodle showcasing Lem's work.
Creating a continuous learning environment is vital for maintaining cognitive diversity, as it encourages team members to continuously develop and refine their skills and knowledge. This environment maximizes creativity and efficiency by promoting the exploration of new ideas and approaches. Cognitive friction, the productive tension that arises from diverse perspectives, can drive innovation and enhance problem-solving capabilities.
Works Cited
Barnouw, Dagmar. “Science Fiction as a Model for Probabilistic Worlds: Stanislaw Lem’s Fantastic Empiricism.” Science Fiction Studies Vol. 6, No. 2 (1979): 153–63.
Brandon, David P., and Andrea B. Hollingshead. “Transactive Memory Systems in Organizations: Matching Tasks, Expertise, and People.” Organization Science Vol. 15, No. 6 (2004): 633–44.
Cave, Stephen, and Kanta Dihal, eds. Imagining AI: How the World Sees Intelligent Machines. (Oxford, 2023). 89-108.
Ellis, Aleksander P. J. “System Breakdown: The Role of Mental Models and Transactive Memory in the Relationship between Acute Stress and Team Performance.” The Academy of Management Journal, Vol 49, No. 3 (2006): 576–89.
Kozlowski, S.W.J. and Ilgen, D.R., “Enhancing the effectiveness of work groups and teams”, Psychological Science in the Public Interest, Vol. 7 No. 3, (2006), pp. 77-124.
Lem, Stanislaw. The Cyberiad: Fables for the Cybernetic Age. (Penguin:2020).
Shelley, Mary Wollstonecraft. Frankenstein, or, the Modern Prometheus. (Knopf: 1992).
Swirski, Peter. Stanislaw Lem, Philosopher of the Future. (Liverpool: 2015).
Weiner, Norbert. Cybernetics or Control and Communication in the Animal and the Machine. (MIT: 2019).
This page has paths:
- The Three Ghosts of Science Fiction Past, Present, and Future Adelmar Ramirez
